"Who Stole My Church?"

I just finished Who Stole My Church by Gordon MacDonald. It's a book I've had on my shelf for nearly a year and I've finally gotten around too. It was recommended to me by Dr. Rob Rhoden shortly before our church (First A/G New Castle) launched our Connection service.

MacDonald writes the book in a different way than I was used to. The book is a fictional story of a realistic situation with possible results. The author did a good job of identifying problems that churches do indeed face everyday; issues including blending age difference, finding a middle ground in music, and you get the idea. The story consists of a Pastor (MacDonald) meeting with a group of older people who feel that there church is being stolen from today's generation. Something very similar to what I've experienced in my own ministry.

What I liked about the book is how easy I was able to identify with what he was describing. There were times in the book where I thought he offered very reasonable solutions in combining generations. After reading the book it did leave me with a positive outlook on my current situation. There is always hope for churches who are still struggling to change.

While I enjoyed aspects of the book, MacDonald took a little too long to say what he wanted to say. There were certain fictional details that could have been left out. Also, I understand the main point he was trying to convey but from a pastor currently navigating the same situation I can guarantee you it is not as easy as MacDonald made it sound. While there will be some people willing to change, it won't happen the same way for everyone.

Overall, I would recommend the book for anyone who is currently serving in a traditional atmosphere but is looking for something else. Otherwise I don't see the need for reading this book.

My Rating: 6/10